2011 NFL Draft: Ravens' Best & Worst Picks
Looking at the eight draft picks that are now the newest Baltimore Ravens, we are going to pick which of them were the best and worst pick in the team's draft this past weekend. Don't be so quick to judge the eight picks in the order that they were selected, as the team got great value in certain picks regardless of the round they were taken in.
For example, both Colorado cornerback Jimmy Smith and Maryland WR Torrrey Smith were projected to go in either the first or second round in many Mock Drafts. However, Jimmy went in the first and the Ravens were able to wait until the 58th pick to get Torrey.
So who do we rate as the best and who gets the "honor" of being the worst Ravens draft pick of 2011?
Even though Jimmy Smith was mentioned by the national media as being one of the best picks in the entire 2011 NFL Draft because while his so-called "character concerns" had many teams avoiding him like the plague, his shut-down cover corner skills may be as good if not better than either Patrick Peterson (LSU) or Prince Amukamara(Nebraska), both who went earlier than Smith did in the first round.
Torrey Smith was thought by many to be going in the first round, and some Mock Drafts even had the Ravens taking him with their first round pick at #26. That's why being able to stick to our draft board and watch him "fall" to us in the second round with the 58th overall selection, makes him the 'Best Draft Pick' of the Baltimore Ravens. Baltimore arguably got a first round talent in Torrey, and they certainly scored a first-round "person" in a young man who has faced a lot tougher challenges off the field than he has or ever will on it.
Jimmy Smith will cover the best receiver on the Ravens opposition and make everyone else's life on defense easier if he can provide single-coverage skills to allow the rest of his teammates to focus their attention elsewhere. Torrey, on the other hand, will not only be that obvious deep threat that the team has lacked, but also a dangerous man every time he touches the ball, be it on a short pass, screen or end-around running play. He will open up the middle for tight end Todd Heap and force secondaries to play single coverage somewhere that will also open things up for the Wide receivers Anquan Boldin, Derrick Mason and even RB Ray Rice. Speaking of Rice, the opposition's secondary will no longer be able to creep up and stock the box to dare the Ravens to throw, as if they make that mistake, QB Joe Flacco should be able to make them pay. That alone will improve the Ravens running game by leaps and bounds.
On the negative side of these "awards," the honor of getting the nod of what appears to be the 'Worst Draft Pick' of the team's 2011 NFL Draft goes to QB Tyrod Taylor (Virginia Tech). This selection by me might draw raised eyebrows by many, as Taylor set tons of records at Virginia Tech and was one of the most athletic QB's in the nation while earning the MVP in the ACC Championship Game, mostly on the strength of his arm by throwing three TD passes while running for another touchdown. Therefore, I would feel much more comfortable if the title was changed to the "Most Questionable Pick" as opposed to"worst."
My reasoning for this pick, although I was looking at one of the other picks from round five through seven as the worst pick, is that it doesn't look promising that Taylor will see the field very often at all. The Ravens might look at him as a kick or punt returner, which could allow him to contribute in some way. I cannot see him making the transition to wide receiver, especially based on our current group, especially the talent we invested in ahead of him in the draft. Finally, you better hope he never gets on the field under center, because that will mean that starter Joe Flacco is either injured or playing so bad he has to be pulled, which just is not going to happen.
Therefore, regardless of the talent he showed at the college level, Tyrod Taylor might not get any real chance to prove he can do it at the professional level and while I still expect the Ravens to find a veteran QB in free agency to back up Flacco, Tyrod Taylor is just not going to be the draft pick we got this past weekend that will contribute as much as the others in 2011 or beyond.
XFINITY is a proud supporter of Baltimore Beatdown. With XFINITY, you can get 120+ NFL games live in HD, recaps of every NFL game On Demand, the fastest Internet, and the best HD experience. Get NFL RedZone on XFINITY to see every touchdown, from every game, every Sunday afternoon! Call 1-800-XFINITY or visit http://www.xfinity.com/mostlivesports to learn more
41 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
What I find interesting...
…is that I’ve read a couple of analysts say good things about Pernell McPhee. Even though he didn’t rack up many sacks at Mississippi State, they feel he can really contribute to stopping the run and putting pressure on the QB. Anyone know anything about this guy? First team all-SEC, team captain (I think; could be wrong), and he tore up junior college in the sack department. Maybe he could contribute this year?
Something like 32 sacks in last two JuCo seasons
but only a few at the Div 1 level. Was team captain and first-team All-SEC, but not that impressed if he can get to the upper level of our depth chart, just like Art Jones.
aka 'Rexx'
McPhee, I think, was a nice pick at the very end of round 5. He was slated to be a 3rd or 4th round pick so to select him near the 6th was nice. He has to bulk up a little bit, but he’s actually really strong at the POA and sheds blocks well, always finding the ball. He had a ton of production at JUCO with over 30 sacks and also put up a lot of pressures. I think he and Art Jones can have a nice rotation at RE.
Worst pick for me is Chykie Brown. He will have a tough time making this team. The Ravens already have a good stable of CBs and I could see this pick as a good depth pick if Brown could tackle, but he’s a diver. He kind of reminds me of Fabian Washington. Good speed and length but not a good tackler. How is he even going to play special teams? I do like that he’s cocky, has length, and can press, but I have some questions about him. He’s coming off of a forearm surgery and I just wonder why that pick was not used on a center or edge rusher. Actually, that pick would have been used on Chris Carter, but the Steelers selected him two picks before.
Taylor IMO was a great pick. I honestly don’t see much of a difference between him and Cam Newton. Blazing speed, great elusiveness and athleticism, and a strong arm. He also is a very smart guy and did more with the VT offense than both Mike and Marcus Vick had to do, as in more responsibilities. I would not mind him as our backup from the start because I think Bulger is gone.
A lot our CBs are free agents, so Chykie should find a spot seeing as how his main contribution will be on special teams. He also played some saftey at Texas, so his versatility alone should net him a roster spot. I read that he even started some games ahead of Curtis Brown, the CB drafted by the Stealers in the third round.
Jimmy Smith and Chykie Brown will replace
Fabian and let’s ay Cary Williams, so they both make the team most likely. I see both Art Jones and McPhee as nothing more than reserves, especially with the depth we have ahead of them.
Taylor, great kids, tons of athletic talent and great resume with amazing stats (move over at VaTech, Michael Vick!), but he will rarely if ever see the field and that is good as Joe is our QB.
aka 'Rexx'
I get the impression the team is high on Cary. He has great size (almost similar to Jimmy), and has been in the system for a few years now. I hear Ozzie loves Art Jones, but without a good training camp, he may fall by the wayside.
I hope we keep Cary around. He was a special teams monster last year. Some of those tackles he made on punts were insane, especially the ones against Cribbs.
Real G's move in silence like lasagna
Cary Williams is an asset to me. Big guys that want to go tackle and can are guys you want to hang on to. He just never got many chances.
by BmoreRavensFan on May 2, 2011 8:08 PM EDT up reply actions
He may go in the numbers game
as Special Teams alone might not keep him around with two new corners just drafted with bigger upsides. I liked him too but he never got the chance.
aka 'Rexx'
by Bruce Raffel on May 2, 2011 10:11 PM EDT up reply actions
I hope Cary and Jones both stick around.
Cary had some big plays last year and Jones has tons of upside though the shortened or non-existent training camps this year might hurt that.
by Roa on May 3, 2011 6:37 PM EDT up reply actions
Marcus Vick was a chump. Mike was the most electrifying player in college football (maybe the pros too). Your qualifying statement “as in more responsibilities” isn’t clear. I’m not sure what you mean by that.
Taylor and Cam are on a different level of play making abilities. While Cam carried his teams to National Championships, Taylor was more along the ride for wins. The Hokies’s offense and game planning was very similar to the Ravens (before last year). Run the ball, play good defense, have great special teams, and let the QB make a play on third down. Taylor did a lot of things well and helped out his team. By no means though was he “the team,” like Cam was.
McPhee does look to have long limps and a good strong frame. I like the pick as well.
Chykie Brown could also play some safety for us. Like you said, he’s another big corner with long limbs. He played against some top flight competition too. He could be a real nice developmental prospect down the road.
I think overall Taylor was a nice pick. I don’t think he matches up physically with Cam, but Tyrod is a heck of an athlete with smarts and the arm to make many throws. I’d like to see him learn from Joe.
by BmoreRavensFan on May 2, 2011 8:10 PM EDT up reply actions
I also want to see Brown suit up and play because I thought that was the most interesting pick. I didn’t expect the Ravens to select another CB.
by BmoreRavensFan on May 2, 2011 8:11 PM EDT up reply actions
Hopefully, we'll never see
Tyrod under center.
aka 'Rexx'
by Bruce Raffel on May 2, 2011 10:12 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
As much as I want to give the vote to my boy Torrey, Jimmy Smith is most likely going to go down as a top 10 Raven of all time. His skill set is unmatched and I could see him becoming a star immediately. Jimmy Smith will be the #1 CB on this team come week 1…..sorry Hines Ward.
Real G's move in silence like lasagna
Agreed that Jimmy will soon be All Pro
but Torrey is actrually a better “value” getting him at #58, and we will see him in a lot of highlights!
aka 'Rexx'
You saw my other reply...
I’m now on Torrey’s bandwagon. No comparison between him and Little.
aka 'Rexx'
by Bruce Raffel on May 2, 2011 10:16 PM EDT up reply actions
I didn’t say already, but with the skill set he has and position he will be playing, Smith has a great chance to go down as one of the all time great Ravens if he hits is potential which could very well be the next Asomugha.
Real G's move in silence like lasagna
Jimmy Smith = one badass mother f***er
Torrey Smith = another badass mother f***er
Is there some sort of award for that?
"Really, all Americans want is cold beer, warm p***y, and someplace to take a s**t with a door on it."
Not sure if anyone has seen this yet
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3VwMQWdRt5g
But it is Torrey Smith in highschool playing basketball. Basically just 7 minutes of insane dunks from him.
Real G's move in silence like lasagna
Here’s hoping Torrey gets his college number 82 , thus helping to begin the end of the Justin Harper experiment….
I hope Harper can get his hands better because he’s shown glimpses of being a nice, big downfield target. Honestly, I liked 14 on him a lot better!
by BmoreRavensFan on May 2, 2011 8:12 PM EDT up reply actions
Harper made the tough catches
but dropped the ones right in his hands. I would have liked to see him get an extended shot, but felt the same way about Marcus Smith. At least Marcus is a ST’s beast.
aka 'Rexx'
As of now, I think Marcus is gone, but I think that’s going to be a really tough cut for Harbs. He loves those special teams guys, and Marcus is one of the best. He can’t catch a cold, though…
yahoo! sports grades our draft as a C+
mostly due to so-called character concerns over jimmy smith.
seriously, they should update their reports on the guy. he’s been clean how long? i don’t think he’s a character concern at all, and i’d grade the ravens draft as an A- (i’d have liked a passrusher somewhere).
"Women who seek to be equal with men lack ambition."
Yeah I don’t like Yahoo and think a lot of them are idiots. They gave us a C+ while giving the Raiders a B+. There were a lot of ridiculous grades on there. I will go for there for sports news, but don’t take any of their opinions seriously.
They gave the Raiders a B+
Because they counted the Seymour trade (thats how they didnt have a 1st round this year) as their first pick. I’d give them a similar grade.
I’d have to give us a B- just because we didnt pick a pass rusher and I think we got a few players that won’t make the roster. We really needed a pass rusher and there were a ton of them in the draft. Had we traded our 2nd round pick and a 5th rounder to move up and select someone we liked, I would have graded our draft as an A+ because we got everything we needed.
As is, we already got 3 opening day starters in the Smiths and Reid without reaching for them. Not many other SuperBowl caliber teams can boast the same fact.
by Mstevens_Design on May 3, 2011 4:38 PM EDT up reply actions
They failed the Bears just because of the trade fiasco.
I mean that was pretty f’d up but when your article is about grading the draft, grade the draft rather than morality. I do read enjoy Yahoo sometimes but the quality is rather low there.
by Roa on May 3, 2011 6:29 PM EDT up reply actions
Well that trade issue
was a part of this draft. They made a huge mistake and failed to make amends for it and in some people’s eyes, that might cost them dearly over the next few years. I don’t think they should have been failed solely for that error, but I can’t argue against it either.
All in all, the grades in that article do seem to be rather wishy washy, but then again why do we really care about the grade now? We have a tendency to get mediocre grades and turn them into gold mines of talent and ProBowl appearances. Some writer or analyst is the least of the team’s concerns. Lets just sit back and enjoy our bounty!
by Mstevens_Design on May 4, 2011 1:10 AM EDT up reply actions



















