Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Most Dangerous Division in Sports

Re-Drafting The Entire NFL

This is definitely not a fantasy football question, although the format is exactly the same What if you could throw every current NFL player back into the draft and start picking the teams from the start. Who would be the first player taken overall and what positions would be the most highly valued? Let's look at what would be my 'Top Ten Draft Picks of Current NFL Players,' counting down from 10th through 1st:

10.  Ray Lewis, LB (Baltimore Ravens): Ray might be on the downhill side of his career but still was 6th in tackles in the NFL. However, his biggest contribution to any team would be his leadership not only on the field but also in the locker room.

9.  Ed Reed, FS (Baltimore Ravens): These first two selections are not the result of "nepotism," as Reed makes every NFL QB locate him on the field before snapping the ball. Depsite missing the first six games of 2010, he still led the NFL with eight interceptions.

8.  Troy Polamalu, SS (Pittsburgh Steelers): Ravens' fans might scream that Ed is a better player, but Troy is three years younger and a more complete player even though they play slightly different positions. Polamalu is a disruptive force along the line of scrimmage as well as in the defensive backfield.

Star-divide

7. Chris Johnson, RB (Tennessee Titans): CJ is a threat t go all the way every time he touches the ball. Give him a decent offensive line and he will run for 1,500 yards and open up the passing game for any team.

6.  Ben Roethlisberger, QB (Pittsburgh Steelers):What, you say, Big Ben on this list? Sorry fellow Ravens' fans, but all this dude does is find a way to win year after year. Eight years in the league and three Super Bowl appearances? The guy makes everyone around him better.

5.  Michael Vick, QB (Philadelphia Eagles): Vick proved last year that he has not lost a step in speed but also has matured into a smarter QB, not just a great athlete. His athleticism is a nightmare to gameplan for and at 30 years old, will only get better, which has to be a scary thought for opponents.

4.  Peyton Manning, QB (Indianapolis Colts): Yes, like Ray Lewis, Peyton is definitely on the downside of his great career (35 years old), but that leadership ability and having a coach on the field will also make the other players around him better. Manning still has a few solid years left in him and having him under center automatically makes any team a playoff contender.

3. Aaron Rodgers, QB (Green Bay Packers): Do we need to add "Super Bowl Champions" to this? At just 27 years old, Rodgers might actually be the first player taken since he has as many as ten more years to lead a team back to the Super Bowl. However, with only three real seasons under his belt, he deserves this ranking but I could not just hand him either of the top two slots.

2. Drew Brees, QB (New Orleans Saints): Brees falls into that category of a great veteran QB with outstanding leadership skills. Only 32 years old, Drew can not only lead his team down the field and into the post season, but get them psyched up before the game as good as any player not named Ray Lewis!

1.  Tom Brady, QB (New England Patriots): Try if you want, but you just can't argue with this top pick. Four Super Bowls, three titles, two MVP's and seven Pro Bowls. Not bad for a sixth round draft pick, eh? At 33 years old, he still had the highest QB rating in the NFL in 2010 and despite his team's early exits in the playoffs the past two years, he remains the best QB in the league and if healthy, could play anywhere from 3-5 more productive seasons, with playoff appearances every year.

Notice how the top six picks were all quarterbacks and there was only three defensive players picked, none in the trenches on either side of the ball? When starting a team that could win right now, while the linemen are long term answers, the QB is the short term solution to winning right now.

Let the debate begin!

Comment 28 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Flacco should be #1 overall.

Real G's move in silence like lasagna

by Mr MaLoR on Apr 15, 2011 12:38 PM EDT reply actions  

Really?

Could have sworn you would have said Troy Smith!

aka 'Rexx'

by Bruce Raffel on Apr 15, 2011 5:04 PM EDT up reply actions  

Kyle Boller

should have been…nvm too sad and not funny

I like Turtles!

by RedTurtle on Apr 15, 2011 8:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

My top 10 off the top of my head…

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Patrick Willis
5. Andre Johnson
6. Haloti Ngata
7. Clay Matthews
8. Troy Polumalu
9. Joe Thomas
10. Nnamdi Asomugha

by BAL_Hawk on Apr 15, 2011 1:15 PM EDT reply actions  

Good list.

A-Rod would be my number one just because of his youth.

by MrPoopyPants on Apr 15, 2011 2:18 PM EDT up reply actions  

Remember:

I made the list based on winning right NOW.

aka 'Rexx'

by Bruce Raffel on Apr 15, 2011 5:04 PM EDT up reply actions  

Peyton Manning is the best QB to ever play the game and still playing like it.

People forgot about him because the Colts had a rough year, but he was single-handedly winning games last season.

by BAL_Hawk on Apr 15, 2011 5:41 PM EDT up reply actions  

Right NOW

Brady is more effective, throws more TDs and has less picks than Peyton. I’ll take him over Manning right NOW.

aka 'Rexx'

by Bruce Raffel on Apr 16, 2011 9:12 AM EDT up reply actions  

Ed Reed= best safety in the league. Polamalu has always been a risk in pass defense. He’s not bad, but he can get cut up from time to time (SB XLV). Ed played what, 10 games? He got 8 picks in that amount of time and led the league in interceptions! Ed is still the best safety and he doesn’t have the pass rush up front to help him out like Troy has. He really benefits from that.

by BmoreRavensFan on Apr 15, 2011 3:07 PM EDT reply actions  

You know a SS plays quite a different role than a FS, right? Troy might, at times, be a risk in pass defense just as Ed Reed is, at times, a liability in run support.

Back on the Sweed train. Choo Choo!
"It’s easy to lie with statistics, but it’s easier to lie without them." -Fred Mosteller

by John Stephens on Apr 15, 2011 3:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

Exactly. Let’s just not argue which one is better and realize that they are the two greatest safeties to ever play the game.

Real G's move in silence like lasagna

by Mr MaLoR on Apr 15, 2011 3:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

I agree

Back on the Sweed train. Choo Choo!
"It’s easy to lie with statistics, but it’s easier to lie without them." -Fred Mosteller

by John Stephens on Apr 15, 2011 4:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

Too bad they don't play serious in the Pro Bowl

Imagine how shut down the NFC would be with Troy and Ed back there?

aka 'Rexx'

by Bruce Raffel on Apr 15, 2011 5:05 PM EDT up reply actions  

Polamulu is the best all around player in the league. If you took away QB’s from this draft, he’d be my number one pick.

I hate giving praise to Steelers.

by MrPoopyPants on Apr 15, 2011 3:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

I’d take Ngata over Troy at this point in their careers.

by BAL_Hawk on Apr 15, 2011 5:34 PM EDT up reply actions  

Ed Reed won DPOY as a SS and if it weren’t for his nagging neck injury that he’s had for about 5 years, he would not be a “liability” in the run game, which is not true anyway. Again, Ed < Troy. The Super Bowl proved that to be correct.

by BmoreRavensFan on Apr 16, 2011 10:39 AM EDT up reply actions  

No love for AP? IMO I think AP is better than CJ, but that’s just me.

by AV23 on Apr 15, 2011 6:30 PM EDT reply actions  

I would also argue Rodgers and Peyton over Brees. Rodgers and Brady IMO are the top two QB’s right now and you can make a case for Rodgers to be #1 as well. I Think he will have another huge year and his team should be back to full health. Because of age and playing level I think he has to at least be number two.

by AV23 on Apr 16, 2011 6:40 AM EDT up reply actions  

CJ is more of a threat to score every time than AP

and Brees is as good or better right NOW and a MUCH better leader than Rodgers.

aka 'Rexx'

by Bruce Raffel on Apr 16, 2011 9:13 AM EDT up reply actions  

CJ is more of a threat to score, but AP is more consistent and harder to bring down. I just think Brees threw a lot of interceptions last year and while he is still a great QB IMO Rodgers has passed him. Other than Brady he was the most consistent QB all last season and that showed by leading his injury depleted team to a superbowl.

by AV23 on Apr 16, 2011 10:22 AM EDT up reply actions  

I see the argument for CJ though because I guess it’s just preference and mine happens to be AP, but I stick by Rodgers being better right now. His rating was 11 points higher without Finley and he added 356 rushing yards on top of it.

by AV23 on Apr 16, 2011 10:31 AM EDT up reply actions  

Your basis for both AP and Rodgers

is valid and while I wouldn’t hesitate to change them to your picks, I’d like to see a real game with Brees and CJ on one team and Rodgers and AP on the other.

The two QBs we’re disagreeing about have won the past two SB’s so both are very, very good. AP had a down year in my opinion, but then again, people might say CJ did too. Both had pretty rotten QB’s, although at least AP had Brett for some of the season. Uhhh,…never mind.

aka 'Rexx'

by Bruce Raffel on Apr 16, 2011 12:34 PM EDT up reply actions  

AP will have better career numbers than CJ when it’s all said and done. Both the guys are fast, but AP adds a little bit more to the equation. If it weren’t for that darn fumbling issue there would be no argument in my opinion.

by Mayne_Event on Apr 16, 2011 12:55 PM EDT up reply actions  

he corrected that this past season though. Only one fumble the whole year.

by AV23 on Apr 16, 2011 5:41 PM EDT up reply actions  

Give me these 10 players.

1. H. Ngata
2. D. Ware
3. Ed Reed
4. Mario Williams
5. Clay Matthews III
6. N. Suh
7. P. Willis
8. Andre Johnson
9. Adrian Peterson his fumble problems almost make me put CJ here… almost.
10. Aaron Rodgers
only 27, he can win big games, lowest interception percentage of ALL QBs***, can make all the throws, and he can actually run for a first down if needed.

-Even better than Tom “Academy Award” Brady.

While I’m at it, I’ll be taking you up on your Tom Brady argument. Put Brady on any other team and he wouldn’t have gotten those Super Bowl rings. The Patriots make the most of all the players on their roster.

by Mayne_Event on Apr 16, 2011 12:46 PM EDT reply actions  

I would have to put P. Willis at number 1

Keep in mind what having Ray has done for our defense for all these years. Having a leader on D like Ray or now Willis can really make a team amazing, especially with a front office like ours.

1) P Willis – Defensive leader and a Ray Lewis clone

2) Aaron Rodgers – Young, talented, and a fighter… What more could you want from a QB

3) Ben Roethlisberger – I hate to do it, but the guy does nothing but win games

4) Tom Brady – I also hate to do this, but I can’t deny it

5) CJ – Crazy speed along with a meaty frame designed to get a ton of touches both between and outside the tackles

6) H Ngata – Devastating force from a position not usually associated with sacks and pressure

7) Peyton Manning – At the downside of his career, but still the best tactical QB in the game, and possibly ever

8) AP – His fumble issues and lack of running between the tackles, while solved last year, puts him below CJ.

9) Vick – Just a sick athlete, with an amazing arm

10) T Sizzle – Unlike Clay Matthews, Suggs would flourish in any defensive system. He also seems to have found his mojo.

I can’t put Brees on the list. I think his ability relies more on the weapons around him. Screens to Bush and the best WR group in the league allows him to do what he does. I would have to put Rivers in front of Brees any day. As mentioned above, I believe that Clay Matthews is really only mediocre in the same way that Adalius Thomas was only mediocre….. the right system makes or breaks this guy.

Unfortunately I can’t put Reed or Polamalou on the list due to injury concerns as well as being in the second half of their careers for 2 naturally physical players. The same goes for players like Ray. I just couldn’t waste a pick on a player that was great, but is limited by injury concerns or just won’t be in the league in 2 years.

I know a lot of people put Andre Johnson on their lists and while he is the best WR in the league, I just don’t see him as a difference maker in many games. There are just too many factors involved in getting him the ball (decent QB play, enough time/ Oline performance, decent running game, etc).

I almost put Hillis on this list but a few things scared me off. For one, we havent seen what type of beating he will take over multiple seasons and that type of RB doesnt last long in the league. Second, I want to see how teams react to him next year. He fared very well all season, even with limited carries and a horrible offense and seems to do well against most defensive schemes (power to run through blitzes and enough speed to separate in the second layer… ala Jamal Lewis). If he has a good year next year and stays on the field, he will break the top 10 in my opinion.

Sorry for the long ass post, but I thought it needed explanation.

by Mstevens_Design on Apr 17, 2011 1:02 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Baltimore Ravens.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Ravens_small
Ravens' Draft Picks: Analysis

Recent FanPosts

Small
Secondary Questions
Small
How I would Have Drafted For The Ravens
Chrisrock_small
An Improved 2012 Ravens Team
Br-ravens2_small
Megatron Can Play Baseball Too!
Br-ravens2_small
NFL / Rich Eisen Podcast Contest
Small
All-time NFL mock draft on MtD
O_s_ravens_small
LeSean McCoy deal with Eagles
Small
Chad Diehl: UDFA
Chrisrock_small
Too Soon? THE FIRST EVER 2012 BALTIMOREBEATDOWN.COM FINAL 53 PREDICTION FANPOST

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Manager

Br-ravens2_small Bruce Raffel

Author

131687683_crop_650x440_small Mr MaLoR

5_small Zachary Beard

30_frankensuggs_news_small lastcallbmore

Reed_small WestminsterRaven

Small RAYven