Baltimore Beatdown: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Fedor vs Rogers Results and Live Coverage

Troy Smith Named Starter vs. Rams

Now that Baltimore Ravens head coach John Harbaugh has named Troy Smith the starting QB for the third exhibition game this Saturday at the St. Louis Rams, it's time to settle this QB Derby. The debate of whether Smith or Kyle Boller should be under center on opening day, September 7th at home against the Cincinnati Bengals should now end for the good of the team.

Everyone, including the new coaching staff, knows exactly what Boller brings to the team. He will be positively awesome one play, and then postively awful the next. The words, "consistency" and "Boller" have rarely been used in the same sentence over his career. He will be a capable backup, whether it be in Baltimore or another NFL city. However, he had had the chance and has proven he is just not a starting NFL-caliber QB. However, the possibility remains that Troy Smith just might be. The second year pro and Heisman Trophy winner from THE Ohio State University has known and faced down pressure all through his college career. Playing in the Big Ten and especially on the road at the Big House at Michigan, in front of over 100,000 maniacs, will make you battle-tested, and Smith has not only experienced it, he has succeeded as well.

In addition, Smith has the attitude, almost cocky at times, that is needed to gain the respect and confidence of his teammates. Almost to a man, the offense seems to prefer Smith leading this offense over Boller, who has frustrated his teammates as well as the fans over the years. At least Smith gives the Ravens a fighting chance, with his legs as well as his arm. While his passing this preseason has not been very good, Boller's has been just as poor. Giving Smith the reps with the first team and the playing time to practice and improve, will give the coaching staff a much better idea of how long we as fans will have to continue to wait until rookie Joe Flacco takes over as the future of the franchise.

Therefore, since I'm sure Ravens coach John Harbaugh reads this column and listens to my impassioned pleas, make the decision NOW! Name Troy Smith the starter for the season and place him under center for the majority of the next two preseason games. Give him ALL the reps with the first team in practice and commit to him for the first part of the season at a minimum, baring injury, that he will be your starter. This will put the Ravens in the best position to prepare for the season and succeed, beginning with an opening day victory over the Cincinnati Bengals.

Thank you, thank you very much!

0 recs  |  Comment 8 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Toober.com

Here’s an awesome free tip for you! and you owe me after this…but Toober.com is always giving away free ravens tickets and they have tons of them. you just go to their blog!

by RavenLvr10 on Aug 22, 2008 11:26 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Smith the starter?

I think you guys are reading the Smith starting this week all wrong. Sure, the Ravens would love Smith to be an answer. However, they know nothing about him, So in an effort to see if he should even be considered over Kyle, they are going to let him play. Good move, as Kyle really has nothing more to prove. Stuck and thrown into a terrible offensive scheme for 5-6 years, no receivers other than Mason for a couple and oft injured Todd Heap to throw to.

Running game has been nothing close to a dominant part of the Ravens offense for over 5 years. Sure agianst weak teams they can thrive a little, but against high caliber defenses, they cannot get the job done on the ground.

Since you are convinced John reads this article, I hope he sees what I have said and would agree, I think Boller IS the starter UNLESS Troy shows so much against St, Louis, he can make the switch.

As a Ravens fan, I am tired of the Boller bashing. There are a limited number of QB’s in this league that are game changers. Boller is better than Dilfer, right? I mean if Trent, who I liked can take a team to the Super Bowl, then Boller can too. But agreed, Kyle needs to lose the shotput motion and start zinging the ball as he can. He is so on pins and needles because of columnists and fans that forget even Johnny U had 20 TD 22 INT years. Every time Kyle makes a mistake, he is lashed. Every time he makes a great play, it,‘s well, it’s about time… why. The guy was great before they brought the wounder McNair in for his last chance. Kyle lit up a bad GB team and lit up a pretty decent contending playoff team in Minnesota. After that, and being replaced, I can only imagine what that does to a person’s mindset. He had turned the corner, and Billick missed it…as he always did with the QB’s..

Remember it was Kyle that almost won the Bengals game last year when McShell, I mean McNair could not get it done. Had it not been for a renegade officals horrible call of pass interference on Heap, people may remember how brilliantly Kyle played at the end. Two GREAT throws coming of the bench in a hostile environment. And, it was Kyle that should have beat NE, had it not been for the coaches ruining the performance in spite of themselves.

So I ask you, can Troy Smith be a pocket NFL QB. He size is concerning, h\s accuracy more so. A gifted talent in college does not always transcend to the professional level. If he was that great, could 30 teams pass him by for 4+ rounds! With all the “bad” qb’s out there, he would have been snatched up. I’m sure Stan White is correct about Troy…. a good leader, good presence and a good guy. But there is an old saying in baseball, you don’t chnage the pitcher unless you kn ow the one in the bullpen is better. In this case, I think Kyle is better, and if he was given the reigns one last time, for the entire year, with the “Billick” gone and Cam in place, I think he could achieve an 85 passer rating and lead this team to 8-10 wins.

BTW, Flacco looks like he will need at least 2 years of watching. Hang tight. The Ravens may have reached too far witrh a guy that has a great arm, but what does that mean. I could throw a football as well as anyone when I was younger….but to be an NFL QB requires more than just an arm. Kyle has the intellegence and grit. I think Troy does too.

In conclussion, I would start Kyle and have 5-7 plays a game scripted for Troy. Like the Steelers did with Stewart. It adds a wrinkle and keeps both men in the game plan. We are going to need all the innovative play calling and execution we can get.

by DTMAN on Aug 22, 2008 12:45 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Ok, Boller had so many chances in baltimore its not eeven funny. He did almost win us dat begals game. i blame billick for the terrieble play calling. The pats game….. makes me sick every time i think of it. we are up by what, 4 and we have the ball wit like 6 mins to play. we are driving down the feild and all boller has to do is make sure we dont turn the ball over. insted, he throws his famous, late game int and…. yall know the rest.

FEAR THE NEVERMORE DEFENSE!!!!!!!!!!!!

by Benji5203 on Aug 22, 2008 8:04 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Used to be a "Boller-Backer"

When the Ravens drafted him, I was super-psyched! I knew of his arm and ability from Cal and hoped the Ravens would take him in the draft. I am fully aware that Johnny U. holds the TD record as well as the Int. record for Baltimore. I wouldn’t have a problem w/ Boller throwing 20 interceptions, but let him also throw 20 TD passes as Unitas did in some years. I believe that Favre has the all-time interception record on his resume, no? The problem is that after five years, Boller still short-arms passes and makes the mistakes that no matter who coaches him or whom his receivers are, the best he could ever hope for is a backup position somewhere in the NFL (New England?). Watch, he’ll go there, Brady will get hurt and Boller will “Earl Morrall” them to the Super Bowl!

Anyway, giving the ball to Troy Smith gives us the advantage of the unknown. He may surprise us and do well, or he may fall flat on his face, at which time Boller will be sitting on the bench ready to do his “thing.” At some point Flacco will be deemed ready and then the Ravens will insert him and determine which of these guys, if any, is suited to be his backup. Face it, they have nothing to lose at this point with Smith and nothing to gain with Boller at the helm.

Unfortunately, in this past off season I would have liked to make Smith or Boller the backup, and sign either Leftwich (now with the Steelers-great pickup) or Culpepper (still available). I’d tell Leftwich (or Culpepper) that they will start the ‘08 season, but will basically be auditioning for the other NFL teams, as Flacco will QB this team in ’09. That way, we’d have a NFL QB at the helm, mentoring Flacco, one who is big enough to take the punishment our offensive line will be “affording” him. That would have been my plan, but unfortunately, I really don’t believe the Ravens nor John Harbaugh actually read this column, although I’m sure they’d benefit and agree w/ me if they did!

Rexx

by Rexx on Aug 23, 2008 11:21 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Troy gives this team the best chance to win, period. The only knock people have against him is his non-ideal size. During the two games he’s started, the team had a much better flow on offense. He even led a win in the regular season finale (granted the Steelers were on cruise control).

To anyone who backs Boller to start, I ask you this: “Has Kyle Boller even WON a game for this team?”. The answer is no, from a game to game basis Kyle can manage the game, but has not shown the ability to take the game over. With Troy, at least we have a guy who can make plays on his feet and through the air. I got a chance to watch Troy play up close and personal for TOSU, and I can tell you right now the kid is a born winner with that extra something special.

by thedecline19 on Aug 23, 2008 3:58 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

In response....

Rexx and all the good fans,

I hear all of you. I will say this. I hope you are right about Troy. If he proves better than Boller, then it’s good for us and I will be happy to be wrong.

1. In the NE game he did not throw a costly int. It led to a NE field goal and they were still winning when Brian as always forgot McGahee had 138 yards and stopped running the ball.

2. He has won many games for us. C’mon, I’ll give you he’s no 4th quarter wonder….but Kyle won against the Jets, despite Herm and Brian both forgetting how to manage the clock.., Cleveland, GB (Sun or mon night), Vikings (Sun or Mon night) and quite a few other Kyle led wins.

3. Rexx, Troy could have had 5-6 more int’s then occured in Seattle and against Pitts. But it’s a new year and I am hoping like all of us Troy is better. As for the 20-22, I hear ya. But we do not have a game plan or receivers that can give that many td’s or int’s. so 10-11 or something along those lines is about the same. And yes, Favre threw tons of int’s and made ton’s of boneheaded plays even as a veteran. Still a pretty good QB though.

I still think if given one last shot, Kyle will do well. If not here, then another team. Look how good Redman looked last year for Atlanta. Granted, they got Ryan, but he looked better there than he did here. Billicked. Grbac, Banks, Mitchell (stunk anyway), so many more. We need Vinny back…nah….just kidding.

Good blog. I will continue to follow you Rexx.

Go Ravens!

by DTMAN on Aug 23, 2008 5:07 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

NO BOLLER

Kyle Boller gets no more shots at quarterback. Kyle Boller stinks and i would rather watch someone else lose. If were going to lose this season, lets make it interesting with someone besides Kyle Boller. Unless you became a ravens fan yesterday we have all seen Kyle Boller. Kyle still wets the bed. Smith, Flacco, yes, Kyle Boller, NO.

by Ravensfan52 on Aug 24, 2008 5:39 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

After last night, who the f--k knows!?

Troy Smith may end up with one big expensive tummy ache, even worse than the one that kept him out of last night’s exhibition game. Harbaugh may just have to name a starter for the first game and Smith unfortunately has done nothing to earn it. Neither has Boller, other than his experience. Perhaps he’ll get the nod and just keep the seat warm until Flacco takes over. My guess will be game ten, the first game after our Bye week. At this rate, isn’t Daunte Culpepper sounding better all the time!?

Rexx

by Rexx on Aug 24, 2008 10:57 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Baltimore Ravens.
Start posting about the Ravens »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Bruce-treetops1_small
What To Look For: Week 9
Atari_small
Greetings (again) from Cincy Jungle
Bruce-treetops1_small
AFC & NFC Players of the Week
Bruce-treetops1_small
AFC & NFC Notes: Week 9
Bruce-treetops1_small
Week 9 NFL Capsules
Save_the_date_small
National Anthem... Another random post.
Bruce-treetops1_small
Week 9 NFL Preview
Save_the_date_small
Anita Marks... Thoughts?
I-beam_small
AFC North schedule analysis: Bengals have edge
Gir_suit_stand_small
Kokinis No Longer Employed by Cleveland

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Arrowhead Pride
Former Chief Pollard Didn't Like Haley's Cursing
Buc 'Em
GAME DAY PROGRAM- (Orange) Bucs hosting Packers
Buffalo Rumblings
Web Rumblings: Buffalo Bills Links, 11/8