Baltimore Beatdown: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: SB Nation Power Rankings: Week 6 Bar-right-arrows



Top Baltimore Football Players of All Time?

A local radio station had a show recently on the top four Baltimore sports people of all time. To me, the top three were easy: Johnny Unitas, Brooks Robinson and Cal Ripken. The fourth could be a slew of people, such as Frank Robinson, Ray Lewis or even someone outside the main sports, such as a Michael Phelps.

This led me to think of whom I'd pick as my top Baltimore football players of all time. For purposes of time and space, I'm looking at the top five list. Five is a decent number, because the first two might be pretty easy to pick, but numbers 3-5 will be extremely debateable. So here's my top five:

1.  Johnny Unitas: This is an easy number one and I doubt anyone would ever even try to debate this choice, as Unitas is arguably one of the greatest QB's to ever play the game. He certainly is the one that modernized it and was the measuring stick of all other QB's for decades.

2.  Ray Lewis:  I'm picking Ray as number two, as he is also one of the greatest middle linebackers to ever play the game and is currently the measuring stick for his generation of players. His jersey is by far the most popular one worn by fans here and is a certain first ballot Hall of Famer when he retires. After 12 years in the league, there is still not another MLB I'd rather have on my team than Ray, including the Chicago Bears' Brian Uhrlacher.

(Wow, it gets hard now!)

3.  John Mackey:   At 225 pounds, he was almost as big as the lineman next to him and bigger than most of the defensive players trying to tackle him. He revolutionized the tight end position from a pure blocker to a key pass catching option. Mackey is slowly dying from Alzheimer's Disease related dementia. He is a mere replica of the bulldozing tight end that terrorized defensive secondaries of the mid-sixties to early seventies.

4.  Artie Donovan:  Yes, I'm picking Fatso! He might not be well known to the younger generation, but the old-timers and true Baltimore sports fans know him as one tough SOB. He's played defensive tackle with a broken leg and was a huge part of the 1958-59 Baltimore Colts NFL Championship teams. He's also one of the funniest guys around and is David Letterman's #1 returning guest on his show.

5.  Jonathon Ogden:  JO was the Baltimore Ravens very first draft pick in 1996 (Ray Lewis was picked in the same year, but later in the first round), their first season in Baltimore after relocating from Cleveland. Since then, he has been a fixture on the left side of the offensive line and perrennial Pro-Bowler. While he is still contemplating retirement as of this posting, there is no contemplating that he will shortly be in Canton, Ohio shortly after retiring.

The next five players would take all day and would continue to spur debate between the current Ravens and the old Baltimore Colts. However, these five should raise enough comments to last awhile. Let me know your top five and why, and we can trade comments on what should be great dialogue on a fun subject.

 

0 recs | Comment 7 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Can only do modern ones

Sorry, but I’m only 16, so I’m not well aware of the Baltimore Colts that well, so I can’t bring myself to rank any of them (even though I know Unitas is one of the greatest QBs ever). So, I’ll have to make my list strictly Baltimore Ravens (ooh so hard, the teams been around for like 11 years, I know right)

1. Ray Lewis
2. Jonathan Ogden
3. Chris McAllister
4. Ed Reed
5. Peter Boulware

5th spot was kinda hard, but there’s my purely Ravens list

by Arichmix on Jun 2, 2008 4:15 PM EDT   0 recs

As tough as it may be...

...based on his record braking season, you just have to put Jamal Lewis on your all-time Ravens list. After putting up 295 yards against the Browns and over 2000 for the season, he has to rank ahead of Boulware, Reed and even McAlister. I’d put them like this:
1. R. Lewis
2. Ogden
3. J. Lewis
4. Reed
5. Stover
Note: Boulware was going to be my #5 guy, but I just couldn’t leave Stover off the list, despite him being a kicker. McAlister is a great CB, but other than a few all-Pro years, he just doesn’t rank above these guys – yet. Also considered: Michael McCrary, Todd Heap, Rod Woodson.
Thanks for the thoughts.

Rexx

by Rexx on Jun 2, 2008 6:27 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Understood

At the 5 spot, I was debating Boulware and McCrary, and CMac is just one of the greatest to wear purple and black in my eyes. The way he’s been bringing it year after year, albeit a rather injured campaign in 07 but he’ll bounce back in 08, just elevates him as one of the greatest Ravens to me. Stover is the man, I agree, and you gotta admire the way he’s been consistently one of the best kickers for over a decade, but I just can’t bring myself to put him in the top 5 over Boulware and CMac.

And maybe my conscience is keeping me from adding Jamal Lewis because regardless of the numbers he put up during his Ravens career and that great season he had, I just would not put him over Boulware and McAllister. I was thinking of Woodson, but didn’t spend enough time on the team as the others, but maybe that’s a shit reason.

by Arichmix on Jun 8, 2008 9:24 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

No offense to Ogden or Lewis...

...but you don’t even talk about putting them on the list until you’ve put Gino Marchetti, Jim Parker, Raymond Berry, and Ted Hendricks on. All four, by the way, in the HOF and named to the NFL 75th Anniversary team. Good call on Johnny U, John Mackey, and Fatso, though.

by JohnnyDouble on Jun 2, 2008 10:07 PM EDT   0 recs

I thought about...

....Marchetti, the Stork and Berry, but Parker is another good selection. I met him once when I was little and he had the biggest hands! I also saw the 75th Anniversary Team, but there were some strange names on the list. Thanks for the thoughts.

Rexx

by Rexx on Jun 3, 2008 9:16 AM EDT   0 recs

Greatest of all time

How about Lenny Moore and Alan Ameche and the Mad Stork Hendricks along with Mike Curtis and Jimmy Orr

by jklein on Jun 5, 2008 6:47 AM EDT   0 recs

Definitely...

...Lenny Moore and perhaps even Ray Berry.

Rexx

by Rexx on Jun 11, 2008 10:09 AM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Baltimore Ravens.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Stampedeblue_small
Ask BigBlueShoe, Colts blogger (Week 6)
Small
Why we will beat indiacrapolis this week
Img_0305_small
McGahee love affair costly
Img_0305_small
4th quarter Ref. decisions should be reviewable
Img_0305_small
Only 4 games to fall on D for a living
Br-ravens1_small
Rolle Out At Least A Month
Small
Our game of the week - TEN @ BAL
Balhawksm_small
Hines Ward Face-Mask
Music-jayz-extended_small
Rivalry is Re-newed
Img_0305_small
Physical Titans?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter