The Ravens need a Big Play WR
I think we can all agree the Ravens have exceeded everyone's expectations and are now a legit contender to not only make the playoffs, but win a game or two. I think we can also agree that the most glaring hole on this team is a big play WR. Derrick Mason is playing at a Pro Bowl level, but to reach our full potential in Cam's offense, we need a strong, fast, big play receiver to pair next to him. While Todd Heap helped fill that role somewhat in the past, he has been a non factor in the passing game this year. Although we most likely will not make any additions until the off season, there is a chance Ozzie could decide that we are close enough to compete for a Super Bowl, and that he will explore adding a stud WR to put us over the top.
The main candidate for an in season trade would be Roy Williams of the Lions. Due to the firing of Matt Millen, it is likely the Lions will enter a rebuilding process, again. It is doubtful that Roy would be willing to waste the prime of his career toiling for a crap team, and due to his free agent status at the end of the year, he will probably be suting up for someone other then Detroit in 2009, regardless. Since they will most likely lose him anyway, the Lions would be wise to explore potential trades in order to get a return on one of their top two assets (The other is Calvin Johnson who is not going anywhere).
The question then becomes, Do we want Roy Williams this year, and what are we willing to give up to get him?
To answer the first question... Of course the Ravens would want Roy Williams, but only at our price. He is a very talented, young WR with great size, although he does have a lengthy injury history which has kept him from becoming a top tier wideout in the NFL. He is 6ft 3in and 211lbs and runs a blazing 4.37 forty yard dash, with a 39.5" vertical. That is pretty impressive, especially paired with his in game highlights, as Roy has been known to make a spectacular catch or two.
The second question is a bit trickier... While we would like to improve the roster now, we cannot mortgage the future, especially with a rookie QB and Head Coach. In essence we would be bidding against the Cowboys, among other teams. I don't think Ozzie would be willing to part with as much as Dallas might be, which would make this trade tough to pull off. Short of giving up draft picks, (I would give up a second rounder, but not a first) the Lions might want Bart Scott or Terrell Suggs, since both will also be free agents at seasons end, and it looks as though the Ravens will not be able to keep both. I would never consider trading Suggs due to his age, talent, and production. Before the season I would have listened to an offer for Bart, as the Ravens will most likely not be able to retain his services this off season, when they hopefully resign Suggs. After watching 3 games, and seeing the Bart Scott of 2006 return, I would lean toward not making this deal. Scott is back to his Pro Bowl ways, running all over the field, pressuring the QB, and laying bone crushing hits onto opposing RB's. On the other hand, he is two years older the Roy Williams, we have Nick Greison and Tavares Gooden to step in at LB, and there is a good chance we will lose Bart in the off season anyway. Why not get something for him?
To be truthful, I would have to watch a few more games to make my final decison on any trade whether it be for picks, prospects, or Scott. As of now I'd lean toward trying to sign Boldin or Williams after the season. One thing is certain though... The need for a big play WR is clear in Cam's offense.
Do you think the Ravens are close enough to explore dealing for a player such a Williams? Or would you rather stand pat and try to pickup a WR in the offseason?
The opinions posted here are those of the administrator of this blog and his loyal readers. They are in no way official comments from the team, and should not be misconstued as such, even though he thinks he could do just as well or even a better job!
13 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Man I'm pickin' up what your layin' down
We need to do it simply because we never have. We have lived with our core D for years and it has not taken us deep in the playoffs. It is worth a shot to get a little more balance. Make the competition game plan against both sides of the ball. I don’t think opposing teams sweat it if they have an injured DB before a Raven’s game. If that’s us we panic..and we do with Wheelchair Rolle. I would bundle up McCallister and Heap for a legit receiver. No problem. Done deal. But….Detroit would turn that down.
I wouldn't give up C-Mac
He’s too vital to our team now. Without him we will get toasted like last year. Heap I’d move for sure, but really, what value does he have anymore? Unfortunately everyone else around the league saw his play this season also. I’m a big Boldin fan and would love to see him lining up opposite Mason. With Willis and LeRon in the backfield, an improving Joe Flacco at QB, and Cam calling the plays, that could be a scary offense sooner then later. Even if our D fell off a bit, we would have more balance, but it’s a tough call.
We need to draft someone.
It always costs more to trade for someone. As talented as Ozzie is, we can get a great receiver in the draft. Bad teams look to trade before they look to draft.
Draft a receiver
I sort of like the idea of trading for Roy Williams but realistically right now it would be better too draft a top receiver in April. Just look at the type of receiver the Bronco’s were able too obtain in the second round in Eddie Royal. This guy is incredible and with out a doubt will be in the running for rookie of the year. His maturity on the field his beyond his years and his ability too adjust too the Bronco’s offense so quickly is uncanny. He went too high school in Chantilly, Va and while I attended high school in the same area until 2004, he was all the talk of high school football in Virginia. He had a great career and will hopefully continue too do so in the NFL. I wish this kid the best for his future. Now getting back too the Ravens I feel like we really need too scout well enough too steal next year’s Eddie Royal. As for this year I believe Cam Cameron will get his receiver’s too perform well under his system when they become more familiar with his tactics, its only a matter of time. I always felt we had potentially great pass catchers in Clayton and Williams but they need the chance too grow and be creative, I feel like Cam gives finally them that.
Eddie Royal is the exception
Drafting WR’s is very risky business. Look through the past 10 years or so of first round wr’s and see how many picks were worth their draft position. Not to say I would be against drafting a WR, but a trade for an established stud would have its upside. They could help right now, before the defense gets old. Your investment might be higher but there is much less risk involved with a Boldin or R. Williams.
As for Clayton and D. Williams, I am not ready to write them off as busts as many have. Even so, I do not think they are the answer to our need for a big play WR. I could see Clayton becoming a solid #2 WR, and eventually stepping into Mason’s spot when he retires. Williams is more of a wild card as he seems to have more potential, but at this point it does not look like he’ll ever be more then a solid #2 or #3. So even if they pan out, which I hope they do, I feel they are complimentary receivers, and we are still missing the beast #1 WR, who we can build our passing game around.
Eddie Royal
Jay Cutler needs to be credited for some of his success. Hopefully Joe F. will progress as Cutler has, which will put our WR’s in the same position to succeed.
Veteran vs. Draft Pick at WR
I disagree about drafting a wideout and hoping they perform the same at the pro level as they did in college. Look at the Steelers’ Limas Sweed, who was taken in round two of this year’s draft. From Texas, standing 6’5", he was thought ot be on eo fht ebetter big guys coming out and has yet to even dress for a game. No, waiting is not what this team has the luxury of, with too many veterans, especially on defense hitting the zenith (good word, eh?) of their careers. Williams would be a great pickup, Boulding even better. I doubt it would take a second rounder to get Williams. If we get him this season before the deadline, we could manage to snare him for a third, perhaps a conditional pick if he gets certain stats, for example. Since he’s going to be a FA at the end of the season, his value is a lot lower than if we was signed to an affordable contract for the next few years. Just like Bouldin, he’s not, although Anquan figures to get the top dollar of the two. Bolding will probably want to go to a more passing efficient team than us, while Williams will do anything to get out of Detroit. Dallas won’t get either as they are infatuated w/ the kid, Miles Austin, who I think looks like the next TO. Besides, they want to get rid of the “bad” Roy Williams and take on the “good” Roy!?
Rexx
I agree with needing a WR now
Drafting a WR will take on average three years to produce, if they ever pan out. (Rexx, I don’t mean to bust your balls, but its Boldin, not Bouldin, Boulding, or Bolding). I think Boldin would come here. I think he wants to be the man somewhere and is tired of being overshadowed by Larry Fitz. With a young Joe Flacco at QB, Boldin would be sure to be a focal point of this offense for years to come. To me, that seems better then the prospect of fighting Fitz for the pleasure of holding up Leinart ’s beer bong for Leinart’s lame duck throws which will come in the near future after Kurt Warner retires.
If we could get R. Williams for a third rounder, I would do it NOW. I am confident we could resign him as he would be so impressed by the culture and professionalism here, compared to Detroit, that he would never want to leave.
As far as Dallas not being interested….Maybe so. But Roy Williams is a Texas guy, and we know how Jerry Jones feels about Texas guys and spending money. It’s the Cowboys, anything could happen there.
Can't wait
I don’t have the patience for draft picks at this point. We need a receiver now. We have a great shot at the playoffs this year. We draft great just about every year but have 1 Championship to show for it. Ray, Mason, Reed, Rolle, McCallister, Price can’t wait and it’s not fair to make them. Trade. We drafted Boller but would have benn better off picking up or trading for a QB. Drafts on O are risky..especially QB.
Thick skin
Not against being corrected, DT and thanks for correcting me, just don’t do it when we’re on the NFL Live in front of the nation! Would you trade Clayton and a middle round draft pick to Cincy for disgruntled 85, and then a high draft pick (3 or 2) for Detroit’s Williams or Cardinals BOLDIN? Then we’d have a pretty good receiver tandum for a long time. Of course, cap wise, we’d lose either Scott or Suggs (see ya, Bart, if I get to choose) and drop Rolle’ and his salary. But we save Mason’s salary, which is roughly the same as Rolle’s (around $6 million). why can’t we do Ozzie’s job?
Rexx
I would do either in a heartbeat but not sure if I'd do both together
I would be worried about combining the ego’s of 8-5 and Boldin. You know one of them will end up complaining if hes not the top guy. I might want to take the route of getting one of the two; whoever is the best value, preferably Boldin. Then pair them with Mason and D. Williams this year, and draft an upside receiver in the second or third round next year. That way we’d have the best of all worlds. A clear cut #1 for my man Joe Flacco for years to come, a great possession type #2 in Mason,an upside #3 in D. Williams, and a project for next year to eventually slide into the #2 or #3 (Depending on D. WIlliams progression) spot when Mason retires.
On the other hand if its only a one year experiment and we would have an option to drop/trade one or the other (with no major cap implications) if it does not work out, then it might be hard to pass up. Can you imagine the Ravens with play makers like McGahee, McClain, Mason, Chad J., and Boldin paired with our young and improving OL and QB. Wow, I think Cam would bust a load in his pants thinking about it….
I think that trading for a WR...
…is a bad idea. I’m a firm believer in building through the draft, but if we could get a young guy that would fit in with Cam’s system, I would not be opposed.
I think that Ted Ginn from Miami would be a good option for us. He’s an up-and-coming burner in the mold of Roy Williams. Not only that, but Cam Cameron drafted him when he was in Miami. Therefore, it’s safe to say that he’d fit in with our system.
As far as Roy Williams is concerned, I’ve heard that Detriot is asking for an arm and a leg before they’ll trade him. Here’s what John Clayton of ESPN had to say about it:
“The big winners from the Evans’ deal, aside from Evans and the Bills, are Roy Williams and the Lions. Williams, who has Pro Bowl talent, is now the top free agent receiver next year. Like last year with Randy Moss and Bernard Berrian, there is a big drop after Williams. Bengals receiver T.J. Houshmandzadeh is probably the next best free agent receiver and he’s in his thirties. The Lions aren’t expected to trade Williams unless there is a ridiculous offer in the next two weeks. That’s unlikely. The plan is to franchise him and try to get maximum value in a trade. Williams can probably ask for $10 million a year. The Lions can ask for more than just a first-round pick. Getting Evans off the market probably helps both sides.”

by 

















