Baltimore Beatdown: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Spencer Hall's Sports Meme Power Rankings

McNair vs. Boller....again!

Well, it's time for our almost weekly debate on who should be under center this week for the Ravens as they prepare to host the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday. Mind you, this should not be a weekly debate, but due to the fact that both Steve McNair and Kyle Boller have taken a significant number of snaps this season, it seems to endure. While Steve McNair has been the starter all season, his injuries have given the opportunities for Boller to step up to the plate and show us what he's got. What he's got has not been overly impressive, as his stats are not significantly better than McNair's in comparison. However, there are a couple of obvious points to consider when looking at the remainder of the season and beyond into the future of this franchise.

As everyone has seen, especially since the debacle on national TV, McNair plays a lot older than his already-ancient 34 years. His body has been battered over the years and the toll taken has compounded to a point this season that it is just time for him to assume the "Vinny Testaverde" role on this team. Whether or not his injuries subside, his body will not be getting better to the point that he will be rejuvenated a la 38 year old Brett Favre. Favre threw the ball 60 yards off his back foot last week. McNair probably couldn't throw it 60 yards with a running start! "Air" McNair used to frustrate defenses with his strong, accurate arm, his legs and tackle-breaking ability, all of which no longer exist as a threat. Therefore, the defense can blitz all day, knowing that not only can he not escape their pass rush, he won't be able to burn their secondary with long passes. This also makes it difficult to establish the running game necessary to set up what limited passing attack he might lead. Combined, this is why all season long, watching this offense operate has been a painful experience for Baltimore Ravens fans.

As critical as I've been, along with most fans, of coach Brian Billick's playcalling, perhaps he gets a pass because he knows and realizes exactly what we see each week. McNair is basically done and coach knows that if he calls plays for McNair to go downfield, it will just be even more disasterous. That said, then why is McNair still the starter? I really can't give you one specific reason, but perhaps there are around 11 million reasons (as in $11 million salary)!

Kyle Boller may not have the head or even the heart of Steve McNair, but he does have a few things that McNair does not. The first is a live, strong arm that is unafraid to throw the ball upfield. Give Boller credit, he might not have the best accuracy or field presence, but he can throw the ball on a line much better than McNair. The second is that Boller has strong legs and can run the ball when pressured out of the pocket, which can keep the defense on their toes and possibly lead to an open field for big gains or even the uncovered pass receiver due to his scrambling ability. Third is that Boller is obviously much more healthy than McNair, leading to all of the aforementioned items just being even more obvious. Finally, the most important thing related to the rest of the season and future of this franchise is this: While Steve McNair is just getting older and more frail, Kyle Boller at least has a chance of improving. The next eight games could be another test to see if this extended opportunity has proven if he learned something behind the wise, old man he's backed up the past two seasons. Then, this franchise will have a much better vision of where to go in the offseason, be it rebuilding this team behind (another) rookie quarterback, or around Kyle Boller.

Now is the time to find out which fork in the road this team needs to take. Start Boller, move the rookie and former Heisman Trophy winner from Ohio State, Troy Smith into the backup role and drop McNair to the third string clipboard carrier mentor position - NOW!

Poll
Once again, we ask you who should be the Ravens starting QB?
Troy Smith
27 votes
Steve McNair
5 votes
Kyle Boller
25 votes

57 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 0 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Baltimore Ravens.
Start posting about the Ravens »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Bob-sanders-081107_small
Ask some Colts fans

Recent FanPosts

Bruce-treetops1_small
AFC & NFC Players of the Week
Small
Coincidence?
Bruce-treetops1_small
SB Nation Power Rankings
Bruce-treetops1_small
Week 11 NFL Capsules
Bruce-treetops1_small
Is $10K Fine For Quinn's Hit Enough?
Bruce-treetops1_small
AFC & NFC Notes
Small
FINALLY FIGURED IT OUT
Bruce-treetops1_small
Week 11 NFL Preview
Bruce-treetops1_small
Pro Bowl Voting Still Open
Xc-mad_men_small
Saints ink McCalister for stretch run

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Mobile Live
Garrett Wolfe Out For the Year (Updated)
Mobile Live
Friday Notes: Lions Place Stephen Peterman on IR, Sign Eric Fowler
Mobile Live
Well, Isn't That Special (Teams)?